Article Published on Emerging Leftist Economic Policy in Germany and Its Relation to Democratic Economic Planning

Samuel Decker recently published an article in the German leftist magazine “analyse & kritik” in which he discusses the emerging left economic policy framework, which has been emerging around the work of Isabella Weber and Tom Krebs.
In response to Germany’s ongoing economic crisis to which the government has been reacting with cutting social spending and the ongoing rise of far-right, Weber has published “Anti-Fascist Economics – In Defence of Affordability, Dignity and Democracy” and Krebs “Kapital und Krise – Wie Deutschland aus der Wirtschaftskrise findet – und wie nicht” (Capital and Crisis – How Germany finds its Way out of the Economic Crisis – and how not”). In their proposals strategic price-controls of essentials goods, strategic industrial policy, intensified progressive taxation and socializing or nationalizing certain core economic sectors play a prominent role. Krebs also coined the term “geplante Marktwirtschaft” (“planned market economy”) for his proposal.
Decker judges this to be a positive direction, especially for the tendency of withdrawing certain key decisionmaking from the market and submit them to democratic rule again. But he also asks where the limits of this emerging left economic paradigm lie and if more radical steps might not become necessary if capital strikes or flight might be the response, were some aspects of this agenda be implemented. For these questions he references the work of Pat Devine, David Laibman and the recent work of Aaron Benanav.

“The new developments in left-wing economic discourse are to be welcomed and go far beyond a Keynesian variant of locational nationalism. They open up the possibility of once again understanding economic development as a matter of social shaping, while also raising the question of ownership. They provide important starting points for a transformative economic policy. However, the medium- and long-term connection between the specific proposals and the new overarching economic framework—in which these measures, when fully thought through, can take effect—remains underemphasized. How could price controls, investment guidance, and public ownership be elevated beyond the ad hoc and sectoral levels to become systemic features of an economic order committed to the common good? Which institutions and social forces could support this process, and how could it be safeguarded against opposing economic forces? This represents a shared developmental challenge for left-Keynesian and more radical socialist approaches.”

You can read the full article (in German) here.