On the website Cosmonaut, Theryn Arnold has written a critical review of the book The Blueprint: How Socialism Can Work in the Real World by Bhaskar Sunkara, Ben Burgis and Mike Beggs, which outlines a market socialist model. Arnold’s critique of the book argues that it does not engage with Marxist value theory and state theory and that as a result it is unable to recognise why a socialist society cannot have markets.
A summary of the book can be found below:
For decades, Marxists and socialists have debated the role of markets and their relationship to socialism. The question has usually come down to whether markets can exist without capitalism. Bhaskar Sunkara, Ben Burgis and Mike Beggs think they can, and make the case in their new book, The Blueprint: How Socialism Can Work in the Real World. It claims that socialism indeed can work in a system where “competitive markets and state planning coexist side by side.”[2] Cosma Shalizi calls it the clearest case for market socialism in a generation.[3] In October, defending the book on X (formerly Twitter), Sunkara granted that it proposes a socialized market sector for commodity production, but argued that this sector would have no wage labour, far more even incomes, and an extensive power of exit. Even if it is not the ultimate horizon, he wrote, it is “a radical destination.”[4]
This is quite an ambitious project which should be taken seriously. However, while I may commend the authors for their rigor, the object of that rigor is not the ground on which most Marxists have historically operated; that is, the argument over socialism and markets has turned on the question of value: whether commodity production can be brought under conscious social control, or whether it imposes its own laws on everyone inside it, owners or not. Instead, the authors move the question to two other grounds, namely, the injustice of the employer’s power and the efficiency of prices as a way of coordinating production. Critics of market socialism can concede these points and still hold that commodity production without capitalists is not a destination beyond capitalism. Even if such a model answers complaints people have about capitalism (say: no bosses, far more equal incomes, democratic workplaces, a big public sector), it leaves the root of the problem in place: competition between producers, and the value relation behind it, will keep producing the same grievances.
You can read the article here.
